#OnThisDay: Explosion Aboard Steamship, 1844

Sometimes it angers me that the history classes I sat through as a child and teen didn’t include little bits of information like I’m sharing with you today. Instead of memorizing names of general and battles and dates, how much more interesting class would have been if we’d been told stories like this one.

Knowing this story could have served as an example to students of how history can turn on a dime. I’d like to think students learned that last week when Russia invaded Ukraine without provocation.

The incident I write about today brings to mind the following for each of us to think about: If not for ___(you fill in the blank)____, then ___(you fill in the blank)____ wouldn’t have happened OR would have happened.

The 1840s USS Princeton

I don’t recall ever hearing about the USS Princeton until recently, and I wouldn’t have heard of it then if I hadn’t been looking for a topic for #OnThisDay for my blog.

There have been a series of US Naval vessels christened with the name USS Princeton. The one I write about today, as you can see from my blog post title, was the one built in the early 1840s. It was a state-of-the-art warship powered by coal-produced steam. It was built in Philadelphia and was best-known for its two 12-inch cannons/carronades, called “The Oregon” and “The Peacemaker.”

“The Oregon” was of revolutionary design, made of wrought iron, and manufactured in England. It was designed by John Ericsson, a Swede who later designed the Monitor of American Civil War fame.

“The Peacemaker” was manufactured in New York under the partial supervision of Captain Robert Stockton, a political supporter of US President John Tyler. It’s thought that it was believed and claimed to be comparable to “The Oregon,” but there were design differences and short cuts were taken in The Peacemaker’s testing. This was a recipe for disaster, and that’s what happened on the Potomac River on February 28, 1844.

Let’s set the stage

The state of politics in the United States in 1844 contributed to the inevitable disaster. William Henry Harrison was elected US President in 1840, but he died in 1841 only a month after his inauguration. John Tyler being the US Vice President, assumed the office of President. It was the first time in American history that a president died in office and was replaced by the vice president. Tyler had been a Democrat, but he was elected as a Whig. Soon after he assumed office, he openly disagreed with the Whig Party over economic policy, and the Whigs kicked him out of the party. The Democrats didn’t want him back, so he became a US President without a political party.

Tyler wanted to be reelected President in the 1844 election. He thought by running on a promise to annex the Republic of Texas into the United States would win him the election. Mexico and Great Britain opposed the idea.

To ward off foreign opposition to that annexation, Tyler ordered the construction of the USS Princeton. Most warships in the world at that time were sailing ships or steamships with fuel limitations. The USS Princeton was designed with a collapsible smokestack, allowing it to also navigate as a sailing ship. A hybrid in the 1840s! It’s engine and propeller system were below the water line, making it less vulnerable to enemy attack than ships propelled by paddlewheel.

Back on the scene to partially supervised the construction of the warship, Captain Stockton bragged about the ship’s prowess, calling it “invincible.” He thought by bringing the ship to Washington, DC and entertaining politicians, he’d get the money to build more ships.

What happened on February 28, 1844

An afternoon excursion from Washington, DC on the Potomac River was planned for February 28, 1844. President Tyler (who had no Vice-President), members of Congress along with their wives, and some Cabinet members were wined and dined on the ship and were scheduled to witness the fire power of the ship during three demonstrations.

It was Stockton’s decision to fire “The Peacemaker” for all three demonstrations. After two successful firings, a third was launched in honor of George Washington. On that third firing, “The Peacemaker” exploded, sending its parts – some weighing in excess of a ton – flying across the deck. Eight people were killed and more than two dozen were injured.

Secretary of State Abel Upshur and Secretary of the Navy Thomas Gilmer were killed. If President Tyler had not been unexpectedly detained on the stairs below deck, he undoubtedly would have been standing with them.

The hole in the US Constitution

What happened in US Presidential succession in the 1840s should have been remedied posthaste. It was the first time a Vice President had to step up and into the Presidency due to the death of a President; however, we know from history it was not the last time.

It would be 1967, four years after the assassination of President John F. Kennedy, before the Twenty-Fifth Amendment to the US Constitution would provide a process through which a Vice President would be replaced in the event of the vacancy of that office.

If President Tyler had been killed in the explosion on the Princeton, the president pro tem of the US Senate, Willie Mangum – a North Carolinian who had been one of the founders of the Whig Party – would have become US President. Among other things, Mangum was an avowed opponent of the annexation of the Republic of Texas.

This fact alone brings us back to the fill-in-the-blanks line from the third paragraph of this blog post: If not for ___(you fill in the blank)____, then ___(you fill in the blank)____ wouldn’t have happened OR would have happened.

If you’d like to learn more

If you want to learn more about the USS Princeton of 1844, I recommend https://historynewsnetwork.org/article/181834, by Stan Haynes, published on November 21, 2021. Also, https://military-history.fandom.com/wiki/USS_Princeton_(1843). I drew information from both of these online resources which include more detail than I shared in my post today. In addition, I understand that Stan Haynes has written a historical novel, And Tyler No More, which includes this tragic incident.

Since my last blog post

Our world has changed forever. NATO is being tested like no other time since its inception. No one knows what the future holds for Ukraine, Europe, and the rest of the world. I believe in His perfect wisdom, God doesn’t allow us to know the future.

Until my next blog post

I hope you have a good book to read and time for a creative outlet.

It’s been an unsettling week in our world since last Monday, to say the least. No one knows what this week holds. My heart goes out to the people of Ukraine who are suffering so. May the world continue to condemn Vladimir Putin for his unprovoked invasion of Ukraine.

Thank you for taking the time to read my blog.


16 thoughts on “#OnThisDay: Explosion Aboard Steamship, 1844

  1. Excellent post! Thank you for sharing this historical event. My dad loved to read, and in the last six months of his life, he and I traded copies of over two dozen of Clive Cussler’s thrillers.

    Your post reminded me how Cussler would take an interesting chapter from history, create a fascinating prologue, make that historical fact key to the hero’s ultimate victory, and provide readers with a satisfying wrap up in the epilogue.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. That was a very interesting story Janet and you are right, that is how history should be taught. I find it fascinating to learn these very important parts of US history like the fact that Tyler had no V.P. and how close he came to being blown away and leaving the country without a president, except for the Senate pro–temp. I think we take for granted many things and we are not aware of the things that occurred in days gone by and we should know them. We also see that with the Russian invasion of Ukraine and Putin’s twisted version of history and how he is trying to make people believe he will be the saviour of the Ukrainians who are being mistreated by fascist hoardes of militiamen who are intransigent and murderous and who are being oppressed by the Ukraininan regime and calling to him to rescue them and bring that area back to Mother Russia. Well, he is lying, there is no such dynamic and Peter the Great he is not, although he might fancy himself a Czar re-constructing the Russian empire. In my opinion he will lose in Ukraine just like Russia (USSR) lost in Afghanistan in the 80’s. I have good friends that I love who are from Kiv and thankfully now live here in Spain and I do feel strongly for the people of Ukraine and I pray to God that, alghough you are right, He does not let us see the future, that He take a stand against evil men such as Putin and allow these poor people…good ones and bad ones…a time of peace. All the best Janet and keep up the good work.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Thank you for reading my blog post, Grant. Thank you for sharing that special memory of your dad and Clive Cussler. just realized I’ve never read anything by Cussler. It sounds like I need to remedy that.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Thank you for your comment, Francis. I’m encouraged that Putin is finding more opposition than he expected in Ukraine. This modern-day David and Goliath story is playing out before our eyes, but this David is going to need more fire power to ultimately defeat Russia. The world is finally seeing Putin for the tyrant he is and always has been. His mental state reminds me of that of our previous president. History tells us that horrible things happen when such a leader goes unchecked. Putin is not going to accept defeat any more than our previous president has. I thank God this didn’t happen during our previous president’s administration since he admired Putin so and still does — calling the invasion of Ukraine “genius.” Those two men are mirror images of each other, as far as I’m concerned. Janet

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Thank you so much Janet! This is fascinating. Really ties in to the Tx annexation theme that’s so important in Mexican and US history. On a lighter note, Tippycanoe is famous in our family as an intentional canoe swamping to cool everyone off!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.